Mike Clevinger was good in 2017 -- and has been better in 2018
The Cleveland Indians will be playing baseball after their September 30th regular season finale. They have all but cemented their place among the playoff field thanks in part to a historically bad American League Central, the talents of possibly the best position player duo in Major League Baseball, Jose Ramirez and Francisco Lindor, and their starting pitching. Most believed the Cleveland starting rotation would be a huge asset coming into the season, but few could have expected them to have to be this good. The well-chronicled bullpen issues early in the year could have posed a bit of a problem, had the rotation not been so good. Corey Kluber is Corey Kluber. I pled with everyone 2 years ago to place their faith and trust in Trevor Bauer. Carlos Carrasco has been steady and sneakily very good. And the 5 spot has been held down pretty well by Shane Bieber since his call up in June. Maybe I will write more on any or all of these guys in future days. However, I have had the itch to write about the one unmentioned Indians starter -- Mike Clevinger.
Clevinger was drafted in the 2011 amateur draft by the Los Angeles Angels in the 4th round, 135th overall. He spent the next three years in the Angels organization, reaching high A ball before being traded to the Indians for Vinnie Pestano. He tore up the Indians minor leagues, posting a 2.73 ERA over 26 starts in AA, before jumping to AAA where he spent 17 starts logging 93 innings and a 3.00 ERA. He got the call in 2016 and made 10 starts to the tune of a 5.26 ERA. 2017 saw him start the season in AAA once again, picking up right where he left off -- a 2.65 ERA over 7 starts. Since his call up in 2017, Mike Clevinger has started 48 games, accumulated 5.9 WARP, posted an ERA of 3.15 and a FIP of 3.63. He has been a very good starter despite being the Angel’s 10th ranked prospect at the time of the Indians acquisition and peaking in the Indians system at 7. Despite a (marginally, at this point) better ERA in 2017, something felt different watching Clevinger this year, so I decided to look into it.
First off -- he is lasting further into games in his 2018 campaign. Almost a full inning further, in fact, averaging 6.1 innings pitched versus his roughly 5.1 in 2017. This is, intuitively, driven by throwing less pitches -- which is reflected in both his BB% and K%. His walk rate is down to its lowest number since 2015, when he was in AA Akron, and his K% has fallen a little bit, still at a very healthy 24%. Unsurprisingly, as he is logging more innings due to the longevity, he has posted his best season in terms of WARP to date, already at 3.1 for the season.
Secondly, his underlying numbers look better. The batting average on balls in play against him is sitting at .297, which is right around average -- indicating he’s not riding some extreme luck to his 3.17 ERA. This number was .273 in 2017, which, while not crazy low, is below league average and was probably due for some regression. He has also lowered his FIP from 3.85 to 3.47 year over year. The batted ball profile is largely the same, with soft, medium and hard rates of 18.6%, 47.2%, 34.2% in 2017 and 17.7%, 46.6% and 35.8% in 2018, respectively.
Disclaimer: It’s about to get real nerdy, so if you’re not here for that, thanks for reading we will talk soon. For those that are still here (why?) here it goes:
BaseballProspectus has a really cool new tool measuring tunnel points and release points. It’s a great idea. After all two pitches could move a ton and look like elite pitches in isolation, but if their release points are hugely different, or they don’t tunnel well, you probably won’t see much success. Professional hitters are very good at what they do, if they know what is coming from the point of release… good luck. Their Release Distance stat measures exactly how far apart two back-to-back pitches are released. The smaller the number, the tighter the cluster (thus lowering the possibility of a pitch being tipped to a hitter based on the release points). Clevinger has tightened this cluster since 2017, putting him at just about exactly the average of BaseballProspectus’ sample (2017 pitchers with at least 100 pairs of pitch samples). Average isn’t exactly exciting or flashy, but paired with good stuff, average clustering can be very, very effective. He does have good stuff, by both the eye test and the best attempt at quantifiable numbers we have. Another of the cool baseball prospectus stats measures plate distance, which is the actual distance back to back pitches are when they reach the plate -- Clevinger is above average here with an average of 18.4 inches difference. (This number can be driven by arsenal and pitch usage, but is valuable nonetheless). So, he is releasing these pitches closely clustered (right at about league average) but they are ending up further apart than league average. This is a desirable combination.
Clevinger has also found an impressive propensity to miss barrels in 2018. Among pitchers with at least 250 batted ball events, Clevinger is holding hitters to a meager 3.7% barrel percentage which places him 29th. This lands him right in behind Chris Sale and Patrick Corbin, and directly ahead of Gerrit Cole. That is very impressive company to keep. Clevinger is also throwing about 3% more strikes overall, while getting opposing hitters to swing more often at pitches outside of the zone (31.1% chase rate in 2018, 27.2% in 2017). The overall whiff rate is down a little bit (less than 1%), but he seems to be locating pitches down in the zone a little better this year. In 2017, Mike Clevinger missed down and gloveside quite often, about 13.3% of the time, in fact. He has lowered that rate to 8.57% in 2018.


He is striking out hitters in that general zone (zone 14 in the image below) at a much higher clip this year though (51% versus 39% in ‘17), and despite throwing a much smaller overall quantity of pitches there, he has generated the exact same number of swings at 137 and 4 more overall strikeouts (44 to 40). Presumably, he is making more competitive pitches in this down and gloveside zone and its surrounding areas.

Clevinger tended to miss heavily down and armside with offspeed pitches in 2017, especially with the changeup. Clevinger threw over 17% of his offspeed pitches out of the strike zone, missing down and armside (the very bottom left corner in the strike zones below), as well as 15.69% and 10.92% in the immediate two zones adjacent.


In 2018, he has taken a lot of those misses down and armside and placed them middle-down, while also managing to catch the down-armside corner of the strike zone more frequently. This is important for a few reasons: Clevinger was wasting a lot of offspeed pitches down and armside in 2017 -- and we don't have a way (short of re-watching every pitch) of knowing if these down and armside misses are off the plate by an inch or if they bounced at the feet of right handed hitters. This season, he is making these much more competitive pitches which is helping him last about a full inning longer each time out -- as mentioned above. In 2017 Clevinger missed between the down and armside and down and middle zones 43% of the time with his offspeed pitches. That is a pretty big percentage to throw in a fairly limited zone. In 2018, the number of pitches in those three zones is down to 36%. Spreading the location of his offspeed pitches in general and misses in this specific example helps to keep hitters from being able to hone in on locations in offspeed counts. Lastly, Clevinger tended to miss in this zone I have been discussing (down and armside, in case you haven’t gotten tired of me saying that) with the changeup especially. He has remedied that in 2018 to a degree, throwing them more often in the zone -- which is especially important given the batted ball profile of his changeup. This may be the most important part of this entire argument. His changeup is firmer than league average, and generates more ground balls than average. The Indians placed an emphasis this year on getting more innings out of their starting staff, which probably must mean more balls in play, earlier in counts. When the left side of your infield is Jose Ramirez and Francisco Lindor, it’s not a bad idea to do everything in your power to make those balls in play ground balls their way.
Clevinger has been a very solid major league pitcher for two years in a row now, and had he not been buried in a rotation with Corey Kluber, Carlos Carrasco and Trevor Bauer would be a pretty solid 2 or 3. Regardless, he and the Indians front office and coaching staff have found ways to use his pitch arsenal and the strengths of each pitch to make him even more effective this year than last. I don’t think it is a stretch to say the Indians are trying yet again to create the curve in pitching philosophy. They rode the high strikeout trend (and still do strike out a ton of people), then created the bullpen market that blew up (Hi, Rockies), and now have reeled it back and begun to ask for more innings out of their starters, even if it is at the cost of a few strikeouts (the elite infield defense helps). They continue to try and zig while the rest of the league is zagging, and it seems to be paying dividends.
Comments