top of page
  • Google+ Social Icon
  • Twitter Social Icon
  • LinkedIn Social Icon
  • Facebook Social Icon

Delta Chase Rates and Umpire Effects

Mar 3, 2018
6 min read

In my almost weekly task of finding new ways to explain how umpires stink, I stumbled across a pretty fascinating article by Fangraphs user “mducondi” titled 'The 2016 Strike Zone and the Umpires Who Control It.” Within it, he discusses the increased accuracy of home plate umpires in calling balls and strikes since 2012. He argues that this seems to be primarily from the rise of PITCHf/x and Trackman in providing post-game reports for umpires to grade themselves and adjust. Pretty remarkably, since 2012 the correct strike percentage for Major League umpires jumped 5.9% from 2012-2015 (76.80%-82.70%). This is still far too low (#RoboUmps), but it is an impressive spike in only four seasons. Luckily, ¨mducondi” did all the work -- and it was fantastic work -- on grading out umpires, finding tendencies and trying to explain away the improvements. (With the exception of one point where, since the data downloaded does not show the handedness of the batter he could not necessarily tell why pitches in zones 11 and 13

were called correctly more often than pitches in zones 12 and 14. He hypothesized that lefties just got more inside pitches called incorrectly strikes than the righties, but my best guess would place this blame on umpire positioning. Umpires set up between the catcher and the hitter, so when a right-handed hitter is in the box, they are directly over zones 11 and 13, making it easier to correctly judge the pitch in that location. Due to the fact that there are more right-handed hitters than left, this would explain why in the aggregate, the pitches in 11 and 13 are called correctly more often.) I digress. This data proves umpires are not just getting more consistent within themselves-- which for hitters with strong plate discipline skills is valuable -- but they are as a whole calling a more uniform strike zone according to the rule book.

The improvement in umpire accuracy -- moreover the standardization of the strike zone -- means that hitters can have much more confidence in taking the close ball. If umpires are better at calling them, hitters have to expand less. Basically, it stands to reason that hitters would have more control over their own plate discipline, with less left up to chance. Statistically, the umpires are going to screw up less, so the hitters can have more faith in not being forced to expand. So the first question I asked myself: does this mean that hitters chase rates (and overall plate discipline) would stabilize quicker? There is less variance in called balls and strikes, so would hitters also adjust and be less willing to expand their zone, and would their chase rates stay more constant over a full season as a result? This would ultimately allow front offices to evaluate and have more faith in their evaluations quicker.

Analysis

Using data downloaded from Fangraphs I tried to test the hypothesis. I decided to start by hopping all the way back to the archaic 2007 season. Umpire accuracy has jumped six percent in four short seasons, so more than a decade for hitters seems fair. Using hitters who were qualified at both the halfway point of the season and the end of the season, I measured each hitters delta O-Swing% (how often a hitter chases pitches out of the zone) from the “first half” (All-Star break) to their final number. Of the 150 players who met these qualifications, they averaged a 1.52% change in O-Swing% from the half to the finish line. Next, I ran this same process for 2012. The 2012 season saw 128 hitters managed to qualify at both check marks, and their delta O-Swing% lowered to 1.38%. Finally, I ran the same test on the 2017 season, which yielded 128 players again, and their delta O-Swing% dropped yet again, to 1.19%.

Overall chase rates are not lower -- in fact, the league chase rate was higher in 2017 than in 2007, but hitters chase rates are stabilizing quicker year-over-year. Although it is a very small change, numbers at the halfway point (and earlier) are becoming more valuable every year, and hitters plate disciple is becoming much more consistent and more a direct result of the process of the hitter himself, as opposed to the process of the umpire. This is important for a few reasons: 1.) As we determined, the umpires’ increased accuracy has increased the the consistency and control batters have over their own plate appearances, more specifically their plate discipline skills, which is objectively good for baseball. No one is paying to watch the umpires. 2.) Because of this, teams can make more accurate player evaluations with less data (more is always better, but…) 3.) With less left up to chance, hitters are able to zone in and do more damage on pitches they want within the zone and have less incentive to chase pitches out of the zone, which presumably increases offense (which although some may not necessarily want, is overall good for viewership purposes).

So is the quicker stabilization due entirely to the umpires? Well, no. The hitters have the same access to the PITCHf/x and Trackman data that seems to be making umpires better, but if the umpires never adjusted the hitters would still be forced to chase a little more often to protect against the backwards K. This is the closest you are getting to a compliment for umpires from me.

Interestingly, as has been highly noted, hitter strikeout rates are also climbing as the strike zone tightens. Using data again downloaded from Fangraphs I found the average K% among qualified hitters to climb in each of our three test seasons, beginning at 15.68% in 2007, climbing to 18.16% in 2012 and finally 19.45% in the 2017 season. This is interesting, but fairly easily explained away. First of all, with a tighter strike zone, hitters are able to hone in and try to do more damage on each pitch they decide to swing at. They clearly are doing so, and accepting the consequences of more swings and misses in the process. This is evidenced by the spike in home run rates and extra base hit rates across the league. According to baseball-reference the MLB saw 1.26 HR/game last season, the highest number we have record of, dating all the way back to 1871. (2012 and 2007 each had 1.02 HR/game.) The most recently completed season also yielded a .426 SLG -- good for ninth all time. Hitters are trying to do more damage each time they swing the bat, and taking their strikeouts along the way (to the tune of 8.25 K/game, also the highest number ever recorded).

As to not take away from the guys actually recording the strikeouts (the pitchers) I decided to look at their numbers to try and further explain the spike in strikeouts despite a tightening of the zone. Unsurprisingly, fastball velocity has risen quite a bit. I again downloaded data from the good folks at Fangraphs and ran a simple test to find that among qualified pitchers their average fastball velocity in 2007 sat at 91.2, 92.1 in 2012 and most recently 93.1 in 2017. (It is important to note: this is the average fastball velocity among pitchers, not the average velocity of a fastball itself in the MLB. Meaning, I took each pitcher’s average fastball velocity then averaged those numbers, I did not average the velocity of every individual fastball thrown in the league. So R.A. Dickey who only threw 18% fastballs at a blazing 83.4 mph gets the same weight as Luis Severino who threw 51.4% fastballs at an average velocity of 97.6 mph.

Further, guys who have better fastballs will throw them more, so the average velocity of a fastball thrown in the MLB is likely much higher than the numbers here, but the sentiment remains the same: people are throwing baseballs harder than ever before.) I ran the same test among relievers and unsurprisingly got similar results. Among relievers with a minimum of 50 IP, average fastball velocity rose from 92.8 in 2007 to 93.6 in 2012 and 94.6 in 2017. Pair this with the growing intelligence of front offices and subsequently the uptick in reliever usage and you get a recipe for a rise in strikeouts.

This only furthers the importance of plate discipline. It is hard enough to hit a pitch out of the zone when it is 90 mph, bring it in there at 97 and there is not much point in trying. Just take a seat and save yourself the time and embarrassment. As pitchers throw harder and harder, hitters can afford to chase less and less.

Plate discipline skills are stabilizing faster -- and are more valuable than ever. Despite this, strikeout rates are rising (thanks to increased pitcher velocity) and power numbers are surging. Teams have reacted and players are being paid for these skills. Chase rates as a whole will probably continue to stabilize (ever so) slightly quicker as hitters adjust to increased accuracy of umpires and take control of the tools at their disposal to increase their own accuracy. Despite this increased performance, umpire inaccuracy still plays too large a role in a hitter's plate discipline skills -- a problem for a later day (or #RoboUmps).


 
 
 

Comments


RECENT POST
  • Grey Google+ Icon
  • Grey Twitter Icon
  • Grey LinkedIn Icon
  • Grey Facebook Icon

© 2023 by Talking Business.  Proudly created with Wix.com

​

bottom of page