top of page
  • Google+ Social Icon
  • Twitter Social Icon
  • LinkedIn Social Icon
  • Facebook Social Icon

Cleveland Optimism

Nov 6, 2016
6 min read

Sunday afternoon I hopped in my 2003 Volkswagen and drove from the house I am renting at school in Hillsdale, Michigan 200 miles east to the corner of Carnegie and Ontario. I spent game 5 in Progressive Field with my family and 25,000 other fans hoping the series would end at 5 games. It didn’t. But, it came back to Cleveland for a game 6 with Trevor Bauer on the mound. Boy, that did not go well. But once again, no worries. Game 7 was staying in Cleveland and the Indians were marching Corey Kluber out to the bump. Kluber, at this point, was boasting a 0.89 ERA in five postseason starts. I drove back to Cleveland again for game 7. I was strangely calm for it. Excited, but not as nervous as I had expected to be. I had so much faith in Klubot that I forgot he was human. I also forgot that the Indians were without their silver-slugger outfielder, Michael Brantley. Oh and Yan wasn’t really there. Don’t forget about Carrasco, whose season was cut short by an Ian Kinsler line drive to the hand. Salazar was out in the bullpen, technically available, but not as the Danny Salazar the Indians needed as he was making his comeback from a forearm strain. Finally, Abraham Almonte was not available due to an early season PED suspension. The point is: the Indians were so good in the postseason that I forgot they were without 50% of what should have been their playoff rotation, 66% of what should have been their starting outfield and their starting catcher. No wonder the national “experts” wrote them off.

This is absurd. I’m not even mad that everyone wrote the Tribe off. No “expert” should expect a team to succeed given those circumstances (see what I did there?) But the Indians are a really, really good baseball team. They do a lot of things exceptionally well. As the world saw, the back end of their bullpen is elite and that was (thankfully) left in tact. Everyone knows how talented their starting rotation is. They also have a young infield loaded with talent and a guy named Francisco Lindor. Lindor’s 2016 all-star campaign resulted in a 6.3 WAR (according to FanGraphs). The guy is above average in just about every category one could think of. Offense? Lindor produced a 112 wRC+. Defense? Gold Glove finalist and a 20.8 UZR (!!!) For reference, that means he is roughly 20.8 runs better defensively than the average shortstop and only one shortstop (Brandon Crawford) was better. Baserunning? Slightly above average, with a BsR of 1. He also leads the league in smiles and high-fives. Oh yeah, he’s also 22 years old.

Directly to Lindor’s right at third base resides Jose Ramirez who stole the hearts of Cleveland fans one clutch at bat after another. The orange-haired infielder swung his way to a 122 wRC+ following back-to-back seasons of below average offensive performance (wRC+ of 81 and 73, respectively). He is above average defensively at third with a 3.2 UZR and a great base runner notching an 8.8 BsR which included 22 steals. His 4.8 WAR places him firmly in the top ten among third basemen. As if you needed any more reason to love the guy, he’s still just 24 years of age.

Now for Carlos Santana, the (unwarranted) punching bag of Cleveland fans for years. All this guy managed to do was post a 132 wRC+, a walk rate equivalent to his k rate (at 14.4%) and set a career high in home runs at 34. He is a professional baseball masher and boy does he mash baseballs. He also is a professional walk-taker and boy does he take walks. (To quickly address my “unwarranted” comment, The Axeman has been above average offensively every single year since he’s been in the league, all while playing 5 different positions). “BUT HIS BATTING AVERAGE!!!” No.... No. No. No. But, just to please the old-school fans (because Carlos is a people-pleaser) he decided to boost that too, up to a very respectable .259. Cleveland fans have nothing left in the tank. They have exhausted all of their misinformed hate-mongering directed at Carlos and now have no choice but to hop on the Santana bandwagon and hold on tight. He will more than likely be the Indians top offensive player yet again next year, and if he is not it will not be due to lack of performance on his part but rather another player exceeding expectations (I’m looking at you JRam.)

If you’re not feeling good enough yet, the Indians second baseman, Jason Kipnis, posted a 4.8 WAR, 117 wRC+ and hit 23 home runs in his most complete and consistent season yet. Mike Napoli had a career year as well, hitting 34 home runs, 113 wRC+ and a 1.0 WAR. The Indians will presumably offer him a qualifying offer, but the expectation seems to be for him to turn it down and walk.

The Indians biggest problems seem to be their outfield and catching. The good news behind the plate is the Indians CAN’T POSSIBLY be worse offensively than they were in 2016. Yan Gomes posted an absolutely atrocious 33 wRC+ in 74 games as he battled injury. Roberto Perez and Chris Giminez did the bulk of the catching in his place, though they did not find much more success at the plate, both hovering right around 60 in wRC+.

This year fans saw primarily a combination of Coco Crisp/Brandon Guyer/Abraham Almonte in LF, Rajai Davis/Tyler Naquin in CF and Lonnie Chisenhall in RF. Chisenhall pieced together a solid season with a 1.2 WAR and 103 wRC+. Naquin had a seemingly impressive offensive rookie campaign, posting a 135 wRC+. His defense was subject (-6.3 UZR) and the peripherals don’t seem to be pointing towards him repeating the success he had (31% K, .411 BABIP). Steamer projects a below average offensive season from him next year with a 95 wRC+. They also do not project his plate discipline to get much better, with a bad BB/K of .31. Naquin also really struggled at the end of the season. However, you can not discredit the offensive value he did provide, especially in the middle parts of the year.

Brandon Guyer, acquired at the trade deadline from Tampa Bay, absolutely annihilates left-handed pitching. He also loves taking fastballs/breaking balls/bowling balls/anything you want to throw his way to any part of his body. The guy(er) does not care what it is, how hard it is moving or where it is going to hit him, if the result is Brandon Guyer running to first base and getting to stay there, Brandon Guyer will wear it. When he is not taking 95 MPH fastballs to the ankles, he just hits his way on base. He posted a 1.021 OPS against lefties in 2016. Although against righties, Guyer did not fare so well, posting a meager .628 OPS. As a member of a platoon or off the bench to face lefties, Brandon Guyer is a very valuable member of the Indians.

Coco will not be with the Indians come 2017 (phew). There is an outside shot Rajai will be, though. Indians fans did not get to see Abraham Almonte do everything at 150 MPH for a large portion of the year due to a PED suspension. Indians fans also did not get to watch their all-star outfielder Michael Brantley due to complications from a shoulder injury. In 2014 and 2015, his last two full seasons, Michael Brantley slapped to the tune of a 151 and 133 wRC+, respectively. He also amassed a 9.7 WAR over that same time period. He is a very, very good baseball player and still not even 30 years of age.

There will also be some new face in the Indians outfield. That new face could come from the farm (Bradley Zimmer, Yandy Diaz and/or Greg Allen) or it could come via free agency or trade. I personally expect Yandy to make his way on to the big league team followed close behind by Zimmer. Eventually, I think Greg Allen patrols center field for the Tribe, but do not expect him to break camp with the club. I also don’t think there is a great fit in free agency for the Indians outfield.

The point of all of this nonsense is this: the Indians not only were really good at playing baseball in 2016, they are going to be really good at playing baseball for a few years. I understand baseball is a crapshoot, especially come playoff time. No team should ever expect to make a world series or even the playoffs just because they did it the year before (LOL Royals). However, this club is really good and really young. Their window is wide open. Their starting pitching is elite. They have a ridiculously good back end of the bullpen, young, talented infield and some key pieces returning to a 2016 club that took the 103 win Chicago cubs to extra innings in game 7 of the world series. Step off the ledge, grab some friends, hop on the wagon and strap in. These next few summers are going to be fun.


 
 
 

Comments


RECENT POST
  • Grey Google+ Icon
  • Grey Twitter Icon
  • Grey LinkedIn Icon
  • Grey Facebook Icon

© 2023 by Talking Business.  Proudly created with Wix.com

​

bottom of page