It's Time to Start Believing in Trevor Bauer
Following the game 5 loss to Jon Lester and the Chicago Cubs, I was subject to some pretty angry fans leaving Progressive Field. Most of it directly towards the head of Trevor Bauer. It’s OK that fans were mad (although it was probably a little extreme.) Part of what makes sports so fun is we can watch, interpret for ourselves and react however the hell we want. We can act like an 0-4 night for a reigning silver slugger is the end of the world, or we can act like Michael Martinez actually belongs on a professional baseball field. Both scenarios are equally outrageous, but we can believe them, because sports allow us to. If there was no reaction at all sports would, frankly, be pretty boring. Athletes can (and in my opinion, should) react too, it's part of the allure as a fan -- following a team or athlete that cares. Trevor Bauer cares. Whether he cares about his team or himself: I have no way of knowing (I believe it to be the former). But, at the very least, he cares. How much he cares is actually, in a strange way, a chief complaint among those not-so-high on him. He is not very talkative with the press and oftentimes comes off a little smug after a poor outing. Now, I’m not saying this is ideal. Sure you’d prefer him to take it in stride, attack the next outing, sports cliché, sports cliché. But, just like the fans, Trevor Bauer wants badly for the Cleveland Indians (or Trevor Bauer) to win baseball games and that is evident by how emotional he gets. (For what it's worth, I've actually had the pleasure of meeting Bauer. He was extremely kind and took a few minutes out of his day to chat with me, completely unwarranted. He was genuinely a nice guy.) Beyond that “want” Trevor Bauer is getting better year over year and is actually providing concrete, objective value to the Indians already. A good amount of it, too. Let’s look at a few of those concrete points…
Trevor Bauer has just completed his age 25 season. To put this into context, one simply needs to check out a few of his teammates:
Corey Kluber: Corey Kluber cracked the big leagues in his age 25 season, for a whopping 4.1 innings pitched and an 8.31 ERA in those 4 innings. Kluber’s age 26 season wasn’t exactly stellar either, a season in which he split time between AAA Columbus and Cleveland. In 12 big league starts he amassed a 5.14 ERA while allowing a .293 batting average against. It wasn’t until the next year, 2013 and Kluber’s age 27 season that he really put it together and became the dominant started Cleveland knows today. Trevor Bauer is only 25.
Carlos Carrasco: I’m sure many fans remember the early struggles of Carlos Carrasco. His first extended stint with the big league club came in his age 24 season (2011) in which he made 21 starts to the tune of a 4.62 ERA. He had Tommy John surgery the next year. Following TJ, in 2013 and Carrasco’s age 26 season, he made 7 starts in 15 total appearances and posted a 6.75 ERA in the big leagues. Carrasco began his 2014 campaign in the starting rotation, quickly pitched his way out of it and into the pen where he seemed to figure it out and make his way back into a starting role. He appeared in 40 games, made 14 starts and posted a career best 2.55 ERA. He was 27 during this season. Trevor Bauer is only 25.
Andrew Miller: Andrew Miller was a failed starter all the way through his age 26 season. He had 5 consecutive seasons in which he had cracked the big leagues but only reached the 100 innings pitched mark in one of those (107.1). Only one time in his first six seasons in which he reached the majors did he have an ERA under 5.00 and it was a pretty rough 4.84. It wasn’t until Miller had turned 27 that he was moved into a full-time relief role and really began to make his mark as the lanky lefty equipped with a circumslider straight from the underworld here to embarrass hitters and their entire families one by one. Trevor Bauer is only 25.
Cody Anderson and Mike Clevinger: Let me preface this by saying this is in no way any sort of jab at these two, or the previous three. Kluber and Carrasco are clearly extremely talented front of the rotation guys. The world just got to see how magnificent Andrew Miller is and Cody Anderson and Mike Clevinger are both still very young and could prove to be very good middle of the rotation guys at some point. The point is to show how spoiled we have been with Trevor Bauer. Cody Anderson is older than Bauer, by about a year and Mike Clevinger is less than a month younger. Nobody is claiming those two should have it figured out by now. “They are still young,” they say. Yet so many of the same people are frustrated that Trevor Bauer isn’t perfect. Cody Anderson is 26. Mike Clevinger is 25. Trevor Bauer is also only 25.
Take a step back and realize the normal aging curve of pitchers, especially the recent trend of pitchers in the Indians organization. Pitching is really hard. Especially pitching at the major league level. It is also extremely unique, there is no cookie-cutter way to do it. It takes a lot of time for guys to figure out what works for them. Trevor Bauer has had more success through this point in his career than anyone else in the Cleveland Indians rotation not named Danny Salazar.
Now that we have compared Trevor Bauer to some of his teammates and peers, let’s compare Trevor Bauer to Trevor Bauer. In 2015 Trevor Bauer threw 43% four-seam fastballs and only 12% two-seam fastballs. Opponents hit .272/.502 (BA, SLG) against his fastball of the four-seam variety and .212/.288 against his two-seam. So what did Trevor Bauer do? He worked in the offseason to further develop his two-seam, affectionately known as the Laminar Express, and began relying more heavily on it in 2016. This season he threw his four-seam only 26% of the time and his two-seam 25%. The slugging percentage against his fastball dropped pretty dramatically along with his pretty dramatic change in fastball selection.
What is equally impressive to his ability to make such a large change in his pitch selection is the fact that the Laminar Express’ average velocity is actually slightly higher than his 2015 four-seam fastball. According to Fangraphs Trevor Bauer’s two-seam fastball in 2016 had an average horizontal movement of -8.0 compared to his four-seam horizontal movement of -4.6. It is moving almost twice as much horizontally while maintaining velocity. That’s a pretty solid combination for missing barrels.
Trevor Bauer revamped his curveball a little bit over the past offseason as well. In 2015 his curveball was already a pretty solid pitch, with a 0.55 wCU/C, which is a stat that attempts to provide a value for individual pitches. It is the amount of runs a pitcher saved with that pitch over the course of throwing that pitch 100 times, in this case his curveball (fangraphs). For context, 0 is average. So, 0.55 is a pretty respectable pitch. However, it got much better in 2016. Trevor Bauer’s wCU/C rose to 1.37. At least a portion of this improved success can be attributed to a slight adjustment Bauer made in his curveball movement itself. The horizontal movement from 2015 to 2016 dropped a small amount (6.1 in 2015, 5.6 in 2016) but the vertical movement changed pretty drastically. The 2015 breaker that Bauer was dropping in had a -8.4 vertical movement. In 2016 that jumped to -10.0. Basically, he took some lateral movement off of his curveball and started dropping in more vertical hammers at 77 mph. A fun but probably pretty useless comparison, Clayton Kershaw’s curveball has a -9.5 vertical movement, compared to Bauer’s -10. (However, Kershaw has much less horizontal movement at a tiny -0.9.)


Trevor Bauer also showed some improvements in his BB/9 and HR/9. His K/9 did drop slightly, from 8.69 to 7.96, but his BB/9 fell from 4.04 to 3.32 and his HR/9 fell from 1.18 to 0.95. To explain the lower HR/9 and probably some of the drop in K/9 one needs to look no further than Trevor Bauer’s batted ball spread, which can in turn be explained by his change in pitch selection. In 2015 39.2% of the balls put in play off of Trevor Bauer were ground balls. In 2016, corresponding with the much heavier reliance on the two-seam fastball, Bauer saw that GB rate rise 9.5% up to a very solid 48.7%. He did so while leaving his line drive rate pretty much constant over the year before thus taking that increase in ground balls from almost exclusively fly balls. His fly ball rate dropped 9.9% to 30.8% total. It’s pretty hard to hit a home run when you hit the ball on the ground.
Perhaps the most undisputable reason why Indians fans should start valuing Bauer is purely his durability. In a season when the Indians lost 2 of their top 3 starters for the postseason to injury (both of those two had battled injuries throughout the year as well) it is admirable that Bauer takes the ball every five days, aside from the one rogue drone incident. In each of the last 3 years Bauer has logged at least 150 innings pitched. That is something that none of Carrasco, Salazar or Tomlin have done in that time. He has thrown more innings than anyone not named Kluber on the Indians, and that is not an accident. There is value to being there and being there consistently, and that is exactly what Trevor Bauer has done.
Steamer projects Trevor Bauer to have a 4.23 ERA in 134 innings next season. They project his K/9 to climb slightly as well as his BB/9. Thankfully for Trevor Bauer and the Cleveland Indians, past performance does not dictate future results. If I had any money to bet (I don’t) I would bet that he beats those marks significantly. A coach (@skydancing8 on twitter, if you’re interested) once told me to never bet against stuff. He was talking about Carlos Carrasco in 2013. I told him he was crazy. Carrasco had a 6.75 ERA that year and that wasn’t even his biggest problem. The Indians literally could not get him to stop throwing at people. As I mentioned earlier, Carrasco came back to put up a 2.55 ERA the next year (with no head hunting incidents) and is now a staple in the Cleveland rotation. I’m a believer in not betting against stuff. Bauer works, he studies his craft (if you don’t believe me listen to an interview with him, you won’t understand half of it) and he has very, very good “stuff.” He consistently takes the ball and marches out to that bump 60 feet 6 inches away from home plate and he is only going to get better. Oh yeah, did I mention he’s still only 25?
Comments